| 2017 Prairieland Conference Football All-Conference Teams | ||||
| Black Division: | ||||
| OFFENSE | ||||
| Position | Name | School | Yr. | Award |
| Quarterbacks | Cade Beekman | Lewistown | Jr. | Special Mention |
| Mitch Gibson | Knoxville | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Colton Leady | North Fulton | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Lukas Tinkham | A-Town | So. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Centers | Carter Mason | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Cody Maxwell | North Fulton | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Julien Nicholson | A-Town | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Guards | Gage Coursey | A-Town | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Tyler Grover | Rushville/Industry | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Caleb Harrison | North Fulton | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Ghage Lambasio | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Dalton Crouse | Knoxville | So. | Special Mention | |
| Tackles | Devin Dejaynes | A-Town | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Zach Johnson | Rushville/Industry | So. | 2nd Team | |
| James Thorpe | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Tanner Warren | Knoxville | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Colton Thurman | North Fulton | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Wide Receivers | Hunter Darst | A-Town | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| DaNeil Waters | Knoxville | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Ben Kline | Lewistown | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Ian Mayall | North Fulton | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Jake Porter | South Fulton | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| J.D. Wilson | South Fulton | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Tight Ends | Ken Thomas | Lewistown | Jr. | 1st Team |
| Chris Utsinger | North Fulton | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Lukas Walker | Knoxville | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Running Backs | Jay Allbright | A-Town | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| Ethan Downs | Rushville/Industry | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Basil Buckner | Rushville/Industry | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Case Hennenfent | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Kage Leab | Knoxville | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Seth Clay | Knoxville | Jr. | Special Mention | |
| Logan McCallister | North Fulton | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Jake Myers | Lewistown | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Tyler Shutter | South Fulton | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Kickers | Kennedy Cleer | Lewistown | So. | 1st Team |
| Evan Yaste | North Fulton | Fr. | 2nd Team | |
| DEFENSE | ||||
| Linemen | Gage Coursey | A-Town | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| Ghage Lambasio | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Dash Loving | Knoxville | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Cody Maxwell | North Fulton | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Ends | Ryan Adolphson | A-Town | So. | 2nd Team |
| Brayden Ferguson | Lewistown | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| James Thorpe | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Tanner Warren | Knoxville | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Colton Thurman | North Fulton | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Harley Pemble | North Fulton | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Outside LBs | Case Hennenfent | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| Cayden Bailey | Knoxville | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Jake Porter | South Fulton | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Logan McCallister | North Fulton | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Chris Utsinger | North Fulton | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Ken Thomas | Lewistown | Jr. | Special Mention | |
| Inside LBs | Owen Gray | A-Town | Jr. | 2nd Team |
| Austin Hickman | North Fulton | Jr. | Special Mention | |
| Carter Mason | Knoxville | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Ethan Mikulich | Lewistown | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Tyler Shutter | South Fulton | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Defensive Backs | Josh Asher | A-Town | Jr. | 2nd Team |
| Hunter Darst | A-Town | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Basil Buckner | Rushville/Industry | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Kage Leab | Knoxville | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Cade Donovan | Knoxville | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| DaNeil Waters | Knoxville | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Ian Mayall | North Fulton | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Jake Myers | Lewistown | Sr. | 11 | |
| J.D. Wilson | South Fulton | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Punters | Ethan Downs | Rushville/Industry | Sr. | 2nd Team |
| Jake Porter | South Fulton | Sr. | Special Mention | |
| Ken Thomas | Lewistown | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Blue Division: | ||||
| OFFENSE | ||||
| Quarterbacks | Hayden Bradt | Farmington | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| Charlie McKinty | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Jackson Porter | Illini West | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Centers | Carter Knake | Havana | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Brody Mynatt | B/WP | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Cy Snider | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Guards | Tanner Coulter | Illini West | Jr. | Honorable Mention |
| Jake Garnett | Illini West | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| John Hiel | B/WP | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Broc Shymansky | Farmington | So. | Honorable Mention | |
| Hunter Bitner | Farmington | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Cale Thompson | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Jared Novak | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Tackles | Threal Anderson | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| Kennedy Gooding | Illini West | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Jake Cole | Illini West | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Caileb Johnson | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Alex Taylor | B/WP | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Wide Receivers | Judd Anderson | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Jakob Uryasz | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Vince Lenzi | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Trenton Teel | B/WP | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Tyler Webb | Peoria Heights/Quest | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Tight Ends | Ethan Kenney | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) |
| Henry Lampe | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Dalton Staton | Havana | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Running Backs | Nate Ferguson | B/WP | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Adrian Hinton | Peoria Heights/Quest | Jr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Sam Hedrick | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Luke Wyatt | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Evan Marion | Farmington | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Dash Anderson | Farmington | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Cade Lansford | Farmington | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Nick Vorhies | Illini West | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Colton Sargeant | Illini West | Jr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Kickers | Felix Gomez | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 2nd Team |
| Nick Johnson | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Wences Sanchez | Havana | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Devin Yocum | B/WP | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| DEFENSE | ||||
| Linemen | Dyami Gibson | Peoria Heights/Quest | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Ty Jackson | Illini West | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Jesse LaFollett | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Brody Mynatt | B/WP | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Jon Schmidgall | Farmington | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Jarod DePriest | Farmington | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Ends | Kennedy Gooding | Illini West | r | Honorable Mention |
| Jake Cole | Illini West | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Henry Lampe | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 1st Team | |
| Branden Lance | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Broc Shymansky | Farmington | So. | 2nd Team | |
| Cody Rickard | Farmington | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Dalton Staton | Havana | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Outside LBs | Ashton Newell | Peoria Heights/Quest | Sr. | Honorable Mention |
| Nate Ferguson | B/WP | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Jack Fletcher | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Michael Lord | Illini West | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Luke Wyatt | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Nathan Rushing | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Inside LBs | Jared Crow | Peoria Heights/Quest | So. | 2nd Team |
| Daveon Barnett | Peoria Heights/Quest | So. | Honorable Mention | |
| Chase Gore | Elmwood/Brimfield | Jr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Evan Marion | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team (Unanimous) | |
| Nick Vorhies | Illini West | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Defensive Backs | Nehemiah Butler | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | 1st Team |
| Rico Dixon | Peoria Heights/Quest | Jr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Cade Lansford | Farmington | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Aero VanHouten | Farmington | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Jacob Smith | Farmington | Sr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Colton Sargeant | Illini West | Jr. | 2nd Team | |
| Carter Boyer | Illini West | Jr. | Honorable Mention | |
| Devin Yocum | B/WP | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Trenton Teel | B/WP | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| Punters | Damon Finney | Peoria Heights/Quest | Jr. | Honorable Mention |
| Jackson Porter | Illini West | Sr. | 2nd Team | |
| Devin Yocum | B/WP | Sr. | 1st Team | |
| At Large | Sam Hedrick | Elmwood/Brimfield | Sr. | 1st Team |
