| 2023 Lincoln Trail Conference All-Conference Teams |
| Final Standings |
| Ridgewood (17-3) |
| Mercer County (16-4) |
| West Central (15-5) |
| Knoxville (14-5) |
| Abingdon-Avon (12-7) |
| Annawan/Wethersfield (12-8) |
| ROWVA/Williamsfield (8-10) |
| Princeville (7-13) |
| Stark County (3-15) |
| United (0-16) |
| Galva (0-18) |
|
| 1st Team Pitchers |
| Mya Brown, Jr., Ridgewood |
| Gabe Bryan, Jr., Abingdon-Avon |
| Addie Seitz, So., West Central |
| Elsie Cook, Fr., Mercer County |
| 2nd Team Pitchers |
| Ava Landon, Jr., ROWVA/Williamsfield |
| Sophie Nimrick, Jr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Emma Way, So., Knoxville |
| Lexi Harshbarger, So., Knoxville |
| 1st Team Position Players |
| Madi Frieden, Sr., Mercer County |
| Ailexa Hunter, Sr., Abingdon-Avon |
| Maddy Nelson, Sr., ROWVA/Williamsfield |
| Bailie Ryan, Sr., West Central |
| Shelby Bowman, Jr., West Central |
| Clara Franks, Jr., Ridgewood |
| Taylor Ford, Jr., Abingdon-Avon |
| Gabby Dean, So., Ridgewood |
| Natalie Harshbarger, Fr., Knoxville |
| 2nd Team Position Players |
| Jadyn Wise, Sr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Kennadi Rico, Sr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Paige Huffman, Jr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Kinley McGinn, Jr., Princeville |
| Becca Lindsey, Jr., Ridgewood |
| Riley King, Jr., Mercer County |
| Avery Rigg, Jr., ROWVA/Williamsfield |
| Mekeya Cihla, So., Princeville |
| Natalie Thompson, Fr., Mercer County |
| Honorable Mention |
| Libby Anderson, Sr., Galva |
| Dani Hilgenberg, Sr., Knoxville |
| Lauren West, Sr., Stark County |
| Bailey Ferguson, Sr., West Central |
| Ava Anderson, Jr., Galva |
| Abby Harshbarger, Jr., Knoxville |
| Chesney Secrist, Jr., Knoxville |
| Hallie Schreurs, Jr., Mercer County |
| Taylor Pace, Jr., Ridgewood |
| Alexia Yarbrough, Jr., Ridgewood |
| Shanna Peterson, Jr., Stark County |
| Maddie Hepner, Jr., United |
| Kerigan Lewis, So., Ridgewood |
| Avery Stegall, Fr., Abingdon-Avon |
| Lauren Winters, Fr., West Central |
