| 2023 Lincoln Trail Conference All-Conference Teams |
| West Division |
| United (7-1) |
| Mercer County (7-1) |
| Abingdon-Avon (4-4) |
| Knoxville (2-6) |
| West Central (0-8) |
| 1st Team Pitchers |
| Beau Honeycutt, Sr., Knoxville |
| Tanner Rogers, So., United |
| Carson Boelens, So., Mercer County |
| 1st Team Position Players |
| AJ Jenks, Sr., United |
| Bryce Bigger, Sr., West Central |
| Javin Dellitt, Sr., Mercer County |
| Owen Relander, Sr., Mercer County |
| Jaxon Schultz, Sr., Knoxville |
| Ian Leffler, Jr., United |
| Carter Rothzen, Jr., United |
| Jude Hofman, Jr., Mercer County |
| Carter Redfern, Jr., Abingdon-Avon |
| Kellen Hook, Jr., Abingdon-Avon |
| Kale Breeden, So., Mercer County |
| Nolan Jenks, Fr., United |
| Honorable Mention Pitchers |
| Dawson Fenton, Jr., Abingdon-Avon |
| Lance Baker, So., United |
| Honorable Mention Position Players |
| Landon Winters, Sr., West Central |
| Jacob Quigley, Sr., West Central |
| Lucas Collison, Jr., Mercer County |
| Noah Lenahan, Jr., West Central |
|
| East Division |
| Annawan/Wethersfield (10-0) |
| ROWVA/Williamsfield (6-4) |
| Ridgewood (6-4) |
| Stark County (5-5) |
| Princeville (3-7) |
| Galva (0-10) |
| 1st Team Pitchers |
| Jake McGarry, Sr., ROWVA/Williamsfield |
| Draven Smith, Jr., Ridgewood |
| Garrett Vincent, Jr., Ridgewood |
| Tim Giesenhagen, Jr., Stark County |
| 1st Team Position Players |
| Mason Heitzler, Sr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Austin Chayer, Sr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Graham Wight, Sr., ROWVA/Williamsfield |
| Daniel Kieser, Sr., Stark County |
| Cade Farquer, Jr., ROWVA/Williamsfield |
| Colin Hornback, Jr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Bryan Bertlshofer, Jr., ROWVA/Williamsfield |
| Zeb Rashid, So., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Dillon Steelman, So., Stark County |
| Owen Anderson, So., Ridgewood |
| Zach Arredondo, So., Ridgewood |
| Sean Watt, So., Ridgewood |
| Honorable Mention Pitchers |
| Matt Senteney, Sr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
| Honorable Mention Position Players |
| Josiah Christianson, Sr., Princeville |
| Kellan Keane, Fr., Annawan/Wethersfield |
